Top of page
Technology

Online hate speech is often hidden in plain sight

Close up hands typing laptop

New research indicates the scale of online hate speech may be worse than previously feared due to the implicit ways that some content is phrased.

The study, led by Dr Vahid Parvaresh of Anglia Ruskin University (ARU), found that the majority of posts which meet the description of hateful content do not contain overtly derogatory words or expressions. Instead, hateful sentiments are frequently conveyed through covert or modified wording.

This inventiveness exhibited in the subtle uses of language to express hate online is in many cases believed to be a conscious act designed to lower or remove the risk of detection, in the same vein as the much more blatant practice of inserting intentional typos into disparaging comments.

The findings, published in the Journal of Pragmatics, are informed by instances of online hate speech directed at Afghan nationals in the comment sections of 58 Instagram posts between 2019 and 2021.

Each post was specifically selected for containing a news item about Afghanistan or the Afghan people, who have experienced one of the world’s most extreme displacements in recent times.

Meta, Instagram’s parent company, says it uses artificial intelligence to detect the spread of online hate, with unclear cases referred to review teams. On its platforms hate speech is defined as a “direct attack against people – rather than concepts or institutions – on the basis of what we call protected characteristics: race, ethnicity, national origin, disability, religious affiliation, caste, sexual orientation, sex, gender identity and serious disease”.

Despite this, the study contains numerous examples of comments which, while free of markedly hateful expressions, are unarguably discriminatory against the person being targeted. Such posts, translated from their original language, include:

“If you are that unhappy, why don’t you pack up your stuff and just go back? Every day there are more of you. Thanks to you, there is not even a single house available in the villages and in the outskirts of the towns. You make a lot of money and then keep nagging. If you are so unhappy, stay in your country and make it better.”

“With so much tragedy and war, how come Afghans have not died out yet?

The study’s author, Dr Vahid Parvaresh, Associate Professor of Linguistics at Anglia Ruskin University (ARU), said:

“Due to the availability and spread of computer-mediated communication, instances of hate speech have been on the rise. This is continuing despite varying levels of intervention from social media companies and governments around the world.

“It is especially true for more innovative and creative ways of expressing hate. It seems that these covert methods are allowing haters to avoid detection online and a primary motivation behind my research is to raise awareness of this fact.

“In order to tackle hate speech, more attention needs to be paid—by all stakeholders—to covert and implied ways of expressing hate.”

You might also like

person holding Blindshell Classic 2 person holding Blindshell Classic 2

Vodacom launches accessible smartphone for blind people

Vodacom Group hosted its second Disability and Accessibility Conference on…

A student demonstrates how a robotic exoskeleton allows for strong movement A student demonstrates how a robotic exoskeleton allows for strong movement

NAU unveils wearable robots to aid walking

Imagine a future in which people with disabilities can walk…

Mark and Mabel Ramos Mark and Mabel Ramos

Father develops software to improve skills therapy

Mabel Ramos’s favorite song is “Ghostbusters” by Ray Parker Junior.…

The 4D programmable and low-voltage haptic interface based on elastomer actuators. (A) (i) Concept of a flexible haptic interface based on the low-voltage-driven elastomer actuators for human–machine interaction. (ii) Structure of the actuator prototype, including a multilayer elastomer acting as a stiffness regulator, a charged electret film, 2 electrode layers, and an insulating layer, and the schematic illustration of the actuation mechanism. (B) Performance comparison across 6 dimensions with other reported haptic interfaces. (C) Haptic interface (i) integrated with the skin on a human arm for emotional Braille application and (ii) incorporated into a cane for blind users to facilitate multidirectional haptic navigation. (D) Overview of 4D haptic modulation principles for enhancing emotional and navigational haptic feedback. The 4D programmable and low-voltage haptic interface based on elastomer actuators. (A) (i) Concept of a flexible haptic interface based on the low-voltage-driven elastomer actuators for human–machine interaction. (ii) Structure of the actuator prototype, including a multilayer elastomer acting as a stiffness regulator, a charged electret film, 2 electrode layers, and an insulating layer, and the schematic illustration of the actuation mechanism. (B) Performance comparison across 6 dimensions with other reported haptic interfaces. (C) Haptic interface (i) integrated with the skin on a human arm for emotional Braille application and (ii) incorporated into a cane for blind users to facilitate multidirectional haptic navigation. (D) Overview of 4D haptic modulation principles for enhancing emotional and navigational haptic feedback.

Haptic tech boosts cognitive support for persons with disabilities

The advancements in tactile perception and feedback technologies have propelled…